Sunday, 10 November 2024

Larnach Castle - The Purdie Years (1927 to 1940) - Part Five

William Larnach's 1887 Ballroom and now to
become a Cabaret Venue, taken pre-1935
[Credit Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive]

This Continues my eight part Blog Series on the Purdie family ownership of Larnach Castle. To read the first instalment in this series please click HERE. The following instalment will be published on Sunday the 24th November. My apologies for the delay but I had some trouble with the online draft for (only) the next instalment which unfortunately meant having to re-write the greater portion of it as I only had an older saved draft.  


Announcement Extraordinary!!! 

Larnach Castle Will Not be Closed!! 

In my last Blog, Larnach Castle would be "definitely closed to the public". Therefore, the above bold proclamation in a newspaper advertisement of the 27th February 1937 would have come as a pleasant surprise.

The Year of the Larnach Castle Cabaret, 1937

A helpful information board within the Castle informs us that; 

"While on an overseas cruise [actually only Mrs Purdie], the Purdies rented Larnach Castle to Bob and Vera Sinclair for a year. They [in turn] approached their friend Gwenda Burt with a proposition of running the tea rooms, showing visitors through the Castle and running a weekly cabaret". 

Thus Miss Burt, a well known and accomplished Dunedin contralto singer, lover of opera, thespian, and dare I even add movie star, agreed to take on the daunting task of being the Castle Hostess and would, during this period, live onsite. The same newspaper report quoted above states that Miss Burt planned a; “unique decorative scheme” along with a twice weekly cabaret and that; “We shall expect to have something in keeping with the dignity and charm of the old Larnach home”. 

I am devoting a whole post to this new enterprise as I also found this period in the many layered history of the Castle incredibly fascinating. And, as you will read, I found Miss Burt to be a most interesting and talented lady and it will become obvious why I have devoted part of this post solely to her. And of course, Mr and Mrs Purdie were, during this period, still the registered owners of the property with their household possessions remaining onsite.  


Evoking former times, a String Quartet 
playing in the Castle Ballroom.
Taken on "Snowdrop Day", 11 Aug 2024
[From my own collection]

The Castle Now Open Daily - Except Monday

The Castle would now open daily 2pm to 5pm except Monday, the entrance to the grounds, including a "dainty and different" afternoon tea, being 1s 6d while admission to the Castle would be 1s extra. Busses conveying visitors would continue to run from Dunedin. The whole of the "lower sun balcony" would now be converted into a “Modern Café" [including] the Cabaret in the Ballroom “with exclusive features”. A “general lounge” with separated dressing rooms on either side, also with a well-appointed supper room using practically the whole ground floor. The Ballroom and café would also be available for "special functions". The [old] Billiard Room on the 1st floor, and with a full sized table, was advertised as being "ideal for men's parties!".

The Saturday evening Cabaret, being "evening dress only", would cost 10 shillings for a double ticket with a more informal Wednesday evening "dress optional" dance being held during the Summer months at a cost of 5 shillings. Supper would be included in the entry fee.

The Cabaret Opening

The report of the opening Cabaret at the Castle, being held on Saturday the 20th March 1937, is eloquently described; 

More than a little curiosity was aroused in the new venture, and the crowds of dancers who left the misty atmosphere of the garden for the warmth and brightness of the brilliantly-lighted rooms had still to make up their minds whether or not the new venture was to be a success. 

At the close of the evening, however, the general verdict was decidedly optimistic, and it is more than likely that the weekly Saturday cabaret and Wednesday informal dance will be more and more popular with hosts and hostesses to whom the idea of entertaining their guests by means of a drive already well known all over New Zealand for its beauty, in conjunction with a dance in ideal surroundings, makes an instant appeal.


A Publicity Photo of Miss Gwenda Burt when
playing Miss Sophia Uprington in New Zealand's
First Sound Feature Film, 1935
[Credit : Hocken Collections]

Miss Gwenda Burt, who is acting as hostess, is already well known to the Dunedin public for her work in the Operatic Society and on the amateur stage, and no better choice could have been made. On Saturday she wore a smart gown of floral marocain, and proved herself equal to the many emergencies that seem to occur on these occasions. 

During the evening the lights in the ballroom were lowered and, dressed as a gallant of the eighteenth century, Miss Burt entered, carrying a branch of lighted candles and escorting Miss Audrey Baker, who was dressed as an eighteenth-century lady, to the piano, Miss Baker then playing ‘To a Miniature,’ the words of which Miss Burt sang. During the song four more gallants, with their ladies, paced into the hall and danced a minuet, the song, dance, and general effect being particularly appropriate in the stately surroundings of the castle.“ 


A Larnach Castle and Cabaret advertisement
dated 24th March 1937
[Credit : The Otago Daily Times]


Miss Burt’s Varied Cabaret Entertainment

Cabaret evenings would thus normally commence with pianoforte, singing, and dancing for the benefit of the assembled guests with Miss Burt herself, and always suitably dressed for the part, ably featuring in the singing. Dancing on the sprung heart kauri floor would follow. All music and entertainment would, however, be in keeping with the historic surroundings of the Castle. Locally trained dancers, including women and younger girls who were members of local theatre, singing, ballet and dancing groups, including many still under instruction from their teachers, would regularly entertain Miss Burt's guests. 

The term “Cabaret” should however not be construed with the racier entertainment that might be held in a European 1930’s burlesque style cabaret club. Orchestral music, pianoforte, singing, dancing minuets (a ‘stately’ dance in triple time), ballet, and classic and modern ballroom dancing were, for Miss Burt’s Cabaret, the order of the day.


Cargill's Castle, Dunedin & Venue for the Rival "Cliffs Cabaret",
taken late 1920's,
[Source : National Library of New Zealand] 

A Choice of Cabarets in Dunedin

Advertisements proclaim Miss Burt’s enterprise as being; “New Zealand’s Finest Cabaret”. The popularity of these evenings were such that the newspaper social columns even noted the names of many who were in attendance. But it should be noted that competition for patrons was fierce with the rival “Cliffs Cabaret” (established in 1932) held at Dunedin’s other ‘stately’ venue with its own ballroom (the now semi-ruinous Cargill’s Castle sitting on a cliff top promontory above St. Clair), and the “Moonshine Cabaret” (established 1933) in the former “Eldorado Dance Hall” at 213 George street (where McDonald’s are now located). 


A second Publicity Photo of Miss Gwenda Burt when
playing a Leading Role as Miss Sophia Uprington in 
New Zealand's First Sound Feature Film, 1935
[Credit : Hocken Collections]

The Great Popularity of Dancing

There was, at this time, a wide variety of opportunities for the public to regularly partake in public dancing, the hugely popular Saturday night Town Hall dances (which regularly drew over 800 patrons and with the music often broadcast live on radio) being one example. “Good floors” [i.e. well sprung floors designed for dancing], popular ‘named’ dance bands, and even proprietary sound systems were now used as a selling point. 

But the ‘Cabaret’ style, although coming at an added cost, offered an additional form of entertainment, and along with the usual dancing, would normally be provided within a more intimate venue. And for those who were willing to pay a premium, the Larnach Castle Cabaret clearly sought to provide a memorable and themed evening of entertainment, often evoking a former age, and clearly catering to those patrons who desired a more sophisticated form of entertainment along with traditional – and requisite ballroom type dancing. 

Notorious for its Debauchery

This was opposed to the popular and latest dance numbers and jazz music generally provided by bands performing at the “Cliffs” or “Moonshine” Cabarets or in fact a multitude of public halls around Dunedin. And Miss Burt’s upmarket and refined Cabaret would surely never be compared to the Cliffs Cabaret; “which became notorious for its debauchery during the Prohibition era”, with alcohol being able to be bought from a “secret room” leading to various Police raids (I quote the Cargill's Castle Trust website here). While alcohol was able to be purchased elsewhere, these clubs were unlicensed "dry" premises and patrons could not legally bring alcohol with them. 

While "beer" is mentioned by Miss Burt in a diary she kept at this time (which is noted on a Castle story board), this was in relation to staff over inbibing and drinking "all the beer" on hand to the extent that they became intoxicated. I am assuming that this alcohol was kept solely for in-house use and private functions (perhaps the "men's parties" referred to above) and that tea and coffee, would surely have been the strongest drinks (legally) offered to Miss Burt's Cabaret patrons. At any rate, the premises were, however, still unlicensed.

I see that in 1938 the "Cliffs Cabaret" offered "Accredited membership only" events which was a way to get around the strict licensing laws, thus becoming a "members only" private club so that alcohol could be consumed, but 'supposedly' not sold, on the premises. This is most likely the period referred to above on the Cargill's Castle Trust website. Although the Magistrate expressed some sympathy for the Proprietor he would still be fined £5 for allowing alcohol to be consumed on unlicensed premises. This illustrates how fraught these times were for those wishing to indulge in alcohol consumption on unlicensed premises. This whole subject could truly make for a Blog post of its own.


A Larnach Castle "Cabaret" advertisement from July 1937.
The "Southland Night" alludes to Southland playing for the
Ranfurly Shield in Dunedin on the afternoon of the 31st July 1937
so there would have been many out of town visitors.
[Credit : The Otago Daily Times]

Come and Listen to the Test Match

A novel way to entice guests to visit Larnach Castle took place on the 14th August 1937 when guests could listen on the radio to the Springboks v. New Zealand Test Match live from Wellington. A reliable short wave radio signal would not be hard to pick up from that elevated position, the self-same reason that the local 4YA Radio transmitter was placed along Highcliff Road. 

“All Good Things Must Have An End!”

The Cabaret “Season” would end with a “Final Gala Night” on the 25th September 1937 and the advertisement, “All good things must have an end!” certainly indicates the finality of this enterprise. The final gala night would end with a flourish, a regular dance band being employed, perhaps as a concession by Miss Burt to modern tastes and preferences although traditional dance numbers would have been the order of the day. 

If the Cabaret had been a financial success for Miss Burt, and indeed the Sinclairs (who were the Castle lessees), I cannot say but I hope that she felt that her very hard work in establishing, planning, co-ordinating, and running such as enterprise had been validated. I am aware that the afore-mentioned diary of her time here exists as this is quoted in a Castle history board. Thereafter the café and Castle remained open daily except Mondays. But having only been a set term lease of the property this would sadly be the final mention of a “Cabaret” at the Castle.


A Striking Portrait of Miss Gwenda Burt,
From a published photo, July 1946
[Credit : The Otago Daily Times]


And What of the Talented Miss Burt?

It is a great pity that while Miss Burt played a leading role as Sophia Uprington in New Zealand's first "Talkie" (i.e. sound) movie, "Down on the Farm" filmed in 1934, only brief incidental footage of her survives out of the few very short fragments that are held today in the Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision Archives. If you're interested, she appears briefly on the very right edge of the screen between 2.00 to 2.09 minutes into this film fragment but unfortunately there is no sound footage of her speaking: 

Down on the Farm, 1935 [Clickable Link which will open in a new window]. 

Thankfully, a number of professional publicity photos were at least taken, two being featured in this Blog post with the upper photo being her costume in the above brief film shot. Miss Burt's name would continue to be frequently mentioned in succeeding years in connection with singing, theatrical and repertory productions, sketches and reviews in which she took an active role. She would also be noted in the 1940's for her comedic roles and amusingly, for her, "excellent male impersonation roles" which illustrates the great breadth of her many artistic talents. In 1946 Miss Burt would win the playwriting competition organized by the Otago Area British Drama League for her work; "On the Lap of the Gods" but also wrote and produced "Hallow-e'en at Brig-O-Dene" for a 1948 Burns Club production which would, appropriately, be presented, at Halloween. I have not been able to locate any obituary for her.

A Visit With "Gwenda"

In the course of my Blog and research writing, strange and serendipitous things quite often happen but I found this one rather spine tingling and most definitely took me by surprise. It was only one week ago that, having completed this "Castle Cabaret" post some time ago, I felt compelled to research and write a very brief resumé on "Miss Burt" as a final tribute to round off what I had previously written about her time at the Castle. But to my complete surprise, here I am writing about Miss Burt and thinking what an interesting person she was then, after noting her last address, it suddenly dawned on me that in 1994 I had in fact had the great priviledge of personally meeting and being entertained by Miss Burt in her own home at Somerville street in Anderson's Bay. With no airs or graces about her, I had just remembered her for all these years simply as "Gwenda". Having accompanied a mutual acquaintance who regularly undertook work for her around her home and who thought that she would like to meet me, I was warmly welcomed, invited inside, and sat talking with her in her lounge while my collegue went about his work before joining us later although after the space of thirty years I do not recall the specifics of our conversation. 

As explained below, I perceive now that perhaps not everyone would have so readily received an invitation to enter her 'inner sanctum'. While there was no doubt an air of eccentricity about her I don't mean that in a bad way and i've always truly remembered "Gwenda" as just a lovely lady. But having only recently moved to Dunedin I had unfortunately not known anything about her life, let alone the great breadth of her theatrical or musical talents or legacy. 

Her otherwise standard 1930's bungalow was decorated with a quite amazing array of beautiful and expensive Dresden style porcelain, having been purchased over the years as her wages and budget would allow, being her pride and joy. As to her former employer, I understand that she had latterly worked for Charles Begg and Company Limited, a piano and musical goods retailer. I do wonder now if in fact she had been inspired by Mrs Purdie's passion for collecting fine china and her time residing at and being the Hostess at Larnach Castle? But the value of her collection was such that in the absence of any visible alarm system and no doubt also for her own personal security, all interior doors had been fitted with locks which necessitated using a little key (from memory an Allen type key) which she carried about her to access areas of her home, locking the doors behind her. Thinking back now, I believe she may have had something on her wall alluding to her association with repertory but our memories can play tricks with us after so many years. 

Having remained a well-known Dunedin identity, Miss Burt died in Dunedin in July 1997, aged 90 years. Her ashes were scattered at the Broad Bay Cemetery, a somewhat hidden but lovely, serene place on a small promontary overlooking the Harbour that I often visit when out cycling down the Peninsula. Miss Burt desired that her death not be advertised until after her cremation (possibly due to security concerns for her home) and also that her age not be mentioned in her death notice but I feel that having reached the age of 90 years this should now, after all these years, be celebrated, including her great accomplishments in life. Thank you for the memories Gwenda.

In the next instalment we shall read of the Purdie's return to the Castle. But this period in the Castle's history would also be full of surprises.


All Rights Reserved

To Be Continued At a Later Date

This eight part Blog series featuring the Purdie family ownership of the Castle follows a more or less consecutive timeline through the highs and lows for this period. I will add a link here when the next instalment is posted.

Corrections : This history has been compiled from a comprehensive range of secondary sources. Correction of any unintended errors and any relevant additions in relation to the time period in question are always welcome. Please email me (quoting your source) using the "Email Me" button in the right-hand menu bar. Thank you.

Bibliography & Sources :

- “King of the Castle” by Fleur Snedden 1997 (from my own collection)
-“Larnach and His Castle” by Alfred H. Reed, 1950 (from my own collection)
-“The Ordeal of William Larnach” by Hardwicke Knight, 1981 (from my own collection)
-"R.A. Lawson Victorian Architect of Dunedin" by Norman Ledgerwood (from my own collection)
-“The Garden at Larnach Castle” by Margaret Barker, 2006
- Larnach Castle Staff & Website https://www.larnachcastle.co.nz/
- McNab Room Collection & Librarian, Dunedin Public Library
- "Papers Past" [National Library of New Zealand / Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa]
- (Published) Recollections of Mrs Lorna Mortimer Hormann (née Duncan), 2010
- “The Press” Newspaper, Christchurch
- "The Otago Daily Times" 
- American Express “Insight” Magazine
- Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive (held by the writer)
- Te Papa Tongarewa / Museum of New Zealand
- National Library of New Zealand / Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa
- Hocken Collections / Te Uare Taoka o Hākena
- Trove Newspaper Archive / The National Library of Australia
- "Treasures of the Dunedin Public Art Gallery" by Peter Entwisle, 1990
- Lemuel Lyes Photograph Collection (used with kind permission)
- Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision Archives
- Images from my personal collection

Sunday, 3 November 2024

Larnach Castle - The Purdie Years (1927 to 1940) - Part Four

Mrs Purdie's Antiques Gallery in the Castle Ballroom,
Photo taken pre-1935
[Credit : Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive]

This Continues my eight part Blog Series on the Purdie family ownership of Larnach Castle. To Read the First Instalment in this series please click HERE.


A New Shipment of Antiques

In November 1930 Mrs Purdie advertises that; 

“…she has just received from England two shipments of Antique Furniture and China, all guaranteed by the British Antique Dealers Association as being over 100 years bid. The shipment includes Quaint Old Chippendale Corner Cupboards, Georgian Sofa, Tables, Bow-fronted Chests and Enclosed Washstands; also beautiful and rare specimens of Derby, Worcester, Spode, and Swansea China, many of which are very suitable for Wedding Presents or Christmas Gifts.” 

Not What it Seems

Their niece Lorna, who appears to have been extremely close to her Aunt and Uncle, would often assist her Aunt in arranging the antiques in the gallery. I wonder if any readers today know of or hold items sold by Mrs Purdie in her Gallery? Knowing that Mrs Purdie placed a "Larnach Castle" label on all the items she sold this is definite confirmation of such a provenance. But, as the Castle explained in a post a few years back, people would then mistakenly believe the item they held was once part of the Castle's furnishings and offer to sell it back!

The 1931 ‘Event of the Season’

On the 28th February 1931, Mr & Mrs Purdie would this year host the Dunedin Women’s Christian Temperance [anti-drink] Union for another “Monster Garden Party” with the public being very welcome to attend, being billed as “The Event of the Season”, and held on similar lines – and at the same prices - as the previous year with afternoon tea being supplied for an additional one shilling.


Larnach Castle with the Fountain and Pond on the
Raised Front Lawn, as viewed pre-1934.
[Photo credit : Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive]

Even if the Day is Wet

Bus excursions from Dunedin City every Tuesday and Saturday remained a set fixture, even through the Winter months. Indeed, advertisements emphasize to readers that; “The ideal outing these Winter days is a trip to Larnach Castle”. Heating such a large building will not have come cheaply but the Castle grounds provided plenty of wood for fires and not forgetting that Mr Purdie was a wood and coal merchant with his own transport so this will have reduced costs. Visits were also promoted as worthwhile; “Even if the day is wet”.

A Very Damaging Gale

Being 800 feet high up on the hillside afforded the Castle and grounds very little protection from stormy weather. A terrific gale on the 20th October 1931, and with widespread damage around Dunedin, caused “fully 100 huge pinus insignis trees” on Mr Purdie’s property to be uprooted. Had his mass tree-felling in 1927-1928 further exposed this elevated property to the elements than what would otherwise have been the case? But I do note a further storm in 1975 (the same storm that so visibly destroyed the pine plantations in Canterbury) which caused very considerable damage to the property with a great many trees on the property being toppled.

Vigorously and Tirelessly Promoted

It was perhaps a sign of the economic times that entrance charges to the Castle remained the same even up till 1934. It would appear, however, that the Antiques gallery proved also to be a major drawcard, being vigorously and tirelessly promoted. Alongside advertisements for the Castle is one featuring Mr Purdie’s Furniture Removal business, another complementary income earner and helpful adjunct when it came to moving around both Mrs Purdie’s antique furniture gallery purchases - and sales.


The Castle Auction Advertisement
dated April 1934. This is is the same
Castle photo as shown above

A Sudden and Quite Unexpected Sale

But quite unexpectedly, on the 28th April 1934, the Castle and 35 acre estate were advertised for sale by auction to take place on the 11th June. Suggested uses were a country club, a high-class guest house, a private school or college, or a select tea garden and cabaret. While the reserve was not advertised the terms appear quite generous, being cash, or 10 percent deposit, a further payment of 50% within 30 days, with the balance remaining on mortgage for five years at 3 per cent interest.

As to the reason for this sale, and while no actual reason is quoted, we need to remember that these were the years of the Great Depression and like anyone else, Mr and Mrs Purdie will not have been immune to its effects. But also, Mr Purdie would, in the succeeding years of this decade suffer ill health and this sale could also signal that he had received a medical diagnosis to this effect. But more of this in a later post. A member of the Barker family (who bought the Castle in 1967) has also been unable to confirm the reason for this sudden sale. 

Just "Idle Curiosity"

On auction day upwards of 100 people were in attendance. Expressing the hope that they were all buyers, the Auctioneer opened the bidding but not one bid would be forthcoming. The attendees were only present through “idle curiosity”. Having made the decision to sell one probably cannot underestimate their disappointment.

A Generous Offer to the City of Dunedin

In August 1934, the Finance Committee of the Dunedin City Council considered an offer by Mr Purdie to sell the Castle and grounds to the City Council “on particularly advantageous terms”. As to Mr Jackson Purdie’s “terms”, the purchase price would be £10,000 ($1.5 million in today’s values); “being considerably lower than the [auction sale] reserve”, with £5,000 to be paid in cash and £5,000 to remain on mortgage at 2 percent per annum interest, the principal amount forming a bequest to the city upon the eventual death of his wife. So the Council would only ever need to find the initial purchase price and while Mr Purdie did not expect the Council to use the property to make a profit, he believed that, like public gardens, reserves, parks, baths, the art gallery etc., it simply be considered “an amenity”.


"The Laird O'Larnach" - A Caricature
by R.S. Clark of Mr Purdie which also
alludes to his business interests. 
[Credit : Hocken Collections]

I Shall Gracefully Accept the Decision

As to the reasons for his offer, Mr Purdie writes; 

Probably what has prompted me most to make this offer has been the ever increasing number of people visiting the castle on the two days it has been made available to the public, and the pleasure which they derive from their visit to this historic and glorious old building, and the almost unanimous desire they express that it will pass into the hands of some public body, which will still make it available to the public. In conclusion, I would state that this letter is not intended in any way to embarrass the position. I recognize the difficult days in which we live, and the care that requires to be exercised in the expenditure of public money, taking into account the best interests of all our citizens, and must simply state that the offer was made in good faith, and, whether accepted or rejected, I shall gracefully accept the decision.”

Divergent Views

The Editors of the two main local papers held quite divergent views on the matter. The Editor of the "Otago Daily Times" suggested that the Council could promote the Castle as a “show place” with the grounds administered by the Superintendent of Reserves, with costs to be funded by admission fees.

The Editor of the “Evening Star” took a rather more reasoned, if not blunt, approach stating; 

The castle is not needed as a museum. The museum which we have has been recently enlarged. The collection which delights visitors at Larnach Castle is neither scientific nor historical. There is no reason why it should make a municipal charge, and we are not aware that it is included in the offer. One of the first rules of the housewife’s economics would be ‘never buy things unless you have a use for them’…”.

A Governor-General’s Residence?

A number of newspaper correspondents even (seriously) suggested that the Castle be purchased for the use of the Governor (Governor General) as a Vice-Regal residence. Reference was made to the fact that Lord Bledisloe, the then Governor General, had remarked on the lack of a suitable Vice-Regal residence during a visit to Christchurch upon which their Council had, within 24 hours, appointed a sub-committee; “...to frame a resolution urging the ultimate acquisition of such a residence”.  

The Dunedin City Council however, rightly considered the matter of a Vice-Regal residence, including the cost of furnishing such a residence, to be; 

“...a matter for the state”, and that; “it is impossible to suppose that the expenditure that would be necessary for the purchase and adequate furnishing of Larnach's Castle so that it might be occupied by the Governor-General on his occasional visits could be justified.”

‘Climatic Conditions’ not Advantageous for Elderly Patients

Another suggestion put forward was to use the Castle as a “rest home”. One correspondent was, however, quick to point out that; 

When the Government used the castle in connection with Seacliff Mental Hospital the resident medical officers used often to visit Broad Bay and the surrounding residential areas, and their opinions on the difference in climatic conditions [the castle being built at an elevation of 1,000 feet above sea level] are generally accepted as being the deciding factor in inducing the responsible authorities to remove their charges from the castle”.


An Enlarged view of the Fountain Framing the
Castle Front Entrance, Circa late 1930's / early 1940's
[From my own collection]


No Profitable Use

In late August 1934 the Council Finance Committee regrettably advised that while;

"The terms as set out by Mr Purdie are exceedingly generous… that it could not recommend the acceptance of the offer, as it did not know of any profitable use to which the property might be put if acquired by the City Council… The committee cannot do less than express its appreciation of the vendor’s action in giving the council an opportunity of securing the property on terms particularly advantageous to it… Mr Purdie’s offer, much as it is appreciated, cannot be accepted”.

One has, however, to put all this in the context of the Great Depression to which Council and ratepayers alike were certainly not immune so a “risk averse” approach to expenditure is certainly not surprising.

Still Open – with ‘Free’ Afternoon Tea

Meanwhile, while now obviously on borrowed time, advertisements advise that the Castle and grounds including the Antiques Gallery were “still open” on Tuesdays and Saturdays, the admission charge remaining at 2s 6d with afternoon tea remaining “free”. Advertisements enthusiastically promoted visits to the Castle and what it had to offer; “A lovely outing”, “The Castle must be seen to be appreciated”, the “Spring flowers are beautiful”, and “the surrounding view immense”.


A view of the Castle steps taken by
Thelma Kent in the 1930's. The imposing
carvings were originally painted black.
[Credit : National Library of New Zealand]

Not [ever] Open Sundays

From December 1934, and over the Summer months, the Castle and grounds, and for the first time, would now be open on every day of the week except Sunday, the same admission charge applying. Thereafter, admission reverted to the usual Tuesdays and Saturdays. The Peninsula Motor Service continued to run busses from Queens Gardens up to the Castle on opening days. The popularity of a private visit appears to have been such that regular advertisements were necessary stating almost tersely that; “Larnach Castle is not open to the public on Sundays, please take notice”. The Castle would, while the Purdie's were resident, never open on a Sunday. Even though this decision will undoubtedly have cost them custom, it will certainly relate to their strong Christian beliefs including not wishing to employ staff to work on a Sunday. While stating; “Afternoon tea provided”, the reference to “free” had been dropped by now, perhaps as a way to offer additional paid options. Specific mention of Mrs Purdie’s Ballroom Antiques Gallery as an enticement to visit appears to have ceased at the end of 1934.

A Suitable Venue for Large Gatherings

The Purdie’s would, on the 12th October 1935, again host a Garden Party, being the occasion of the New Zealand Baptist Church Missionary Jubilee Annual Assembly which was being held in Dunedin with; “a most interesting and enjoyable time being spent by all.”    

Between the 25th to 28th January 1935 Mr Purdie generously made the Castle available as a venue for the Dunedin Christian Youth Movement to hold a youth training conference.


"The Old Wishing Well" viewed from all Four Sides.
Words on each side read "The"  "Old"  "Wishing"  "Well".
Taken 11 Aug 2024
[From my own collection]

The Old Wishing Well

In June 1936, mention is made of 'The Wishing Well', a still extant Castle feature on the back lawn originally installed by William Larnach, being sunk to a depth of twenty-six feet and fed by a perennial spring; 

There is an old-fashioned wishing well at the castle where you can have a drink of beautiful fresh water, a wish, and please put a coin in the Children’s Rest Home box which is on the top of the well. We have received about £l5 from this source. We thank Mr and Mrs Jackson Purdie for their kindness in having the box there, and also for their many kind gifts of coal and cartage.”

It should be remembered that handily, Mr Purdie was both a Wood and Coal Merchant and a Carrier.


A 1930's Photo of the "Cannon" under the Cupola and today
[Credit : Te Papa Tongarewa and from my own collection]


Mrs Barker tells the interesting story of how Mrs Purdie acquired the old (and surprisingly small) "signal cannon" that had once been situated at the Taiaroa Head Signal Station and fired to alert townspeople at Port Chalmers when a ship was sighted. Such "black powder" signal cannons, being usually mounted on a carriage as shown above, were traditionally used on sailing ships; "to pass orders and information, to salute other vessels in passing, to sound a mutiny, and in time of fog, as a distance off signal." Replicas are actually still sold today and when such cannons are fired (under fully supervised conditions) they would certainly be heard from a distance.

As noted in my previous post, Mrs Purdie rather trustingly placed the cannon under the cupola. While away from the Castle in 1937, and despite “Caretakers” being employed to care for the property, a party had been held and one of the guests had thrown the cannon down the well. There it remained until the Barkers, and thirty years later, managed to retrieve it by lowering an un-named "thin person" down the well. This would in fact not be the only occasion when objects were retrieved from the well, having been lost by visitors and needing to be recovered. Any retrieval mission would not have been for the faint hearted or someone with a claustrophobic disposition. 

Today the signal cannon, complete with carriage but without the little wheels, can be rather more securely viewed in the Castle's history room. But try as I may, I have been unable to find out any more about its former history other than that I note reference to a "Pilot Station" with a flag staff at "Taiaroa's Head" in 1851 and to the "Otago Harbor [Harbour] Signal Station" in 1862. There is no mention of a signal cannon in the June 1876 published Otago Harbour signalling arrangements and a telegraph line appears to have been employed from the mid 1870's. 

The End of an Era

Worryingly, advertisements from January 1937 state that; “After the end of February Larnach Castle will definitely be closed to the public”.

In early March, Mr and Mrs Purdie, would lease the Castle for “a definite period”, and with Mrs Purdie leaving for "an extended world tour". A Dunedin firm of Auctioneers were entrusted with the sale of the contents of the Antiques Gallery which must have continued trading through 1935 and 1936 although no specific mention is made of this. By this time it would have become very difficult, if not impossible, to arrange the requisite foreign exchange to pay for large shipments of antiques from England and people would not have been spending like they had in pre-depression years.

Everything To Be Sold - "Regardless of Price"

The sale, taking place at Auction Rooms in Moray Place on the 25th February 1937, would feature period furniture, rare crystal, art, china, old silverware and Sheffield plate and a number of Grandfather clocks with every article to be sold, “regardless of price”. The contents of their home would however remain under custodial care.

Since he was also vacating the property, Mr Purdie additionally had a number of farm related items auctioned by The Otago Farmers' Co-Operative Society Ltd at their Burnside Sale Yards on the 24th, including an International mower, plough, horse cultivator, sledge, spring dray, farm dray, harness, and various sundries, all stated to be in "as good as new condition".

With the Purdie's away and the property leased and "closed to the public" the Castle and grounds would now surely expect to enjoy a period of relative peace and serenity. What actually transpired makes for fascinating reading and would further add to the multi-layered history of the Castle. 


All Rights Reserved

This eight part Blog series featuring the Purdie family ownership of the Castle follows a more or less consecutive timeline through the highs and lows for this period. To read the next instalment in this series please click HERE.

Corrections : This history has been compiled from a comprehensive range of secondary sources. Correction of any unintended errors and any relevant additions in relation to the time period in question are always welcome. Please email me (quoting your source) using the "Email Me" button in the right-hand menu bar. Thank you.

Bibliography & Sources :

- “King of the Castle” by Fleur Snedden 1997 (from my own collection)
-“Larnach and His Castle” by Alfred H. Reed, 1950 (from my own collection)
-“The Ordeal of William Larnach” by Hardwicke Knight, 1981 (from my own collection)
-"R.A. Lawson Victorian Architect of Dunedin" by Norman Ledgerwood (from my own collection)
-“The Garden at Larnach Castle” by Margaret Barker, 2006
- Larnach Castle Staff & Website https://www.larnachcastle.co.nz/
- McNab Room Collection & Librarian, Dunedin Public Library
- "Papers Past" [National Library of New Zealand / Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa]
- (Published) Recollections of Mrs Lorna Mortimer Hormann (née Duncan), 2010
- “The Press” Newspaper, Christchurch
- "The Otago Daily Times" 
- American Express “Insight” Magazine
- Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive (held by the writer)
- Te Papa Tongarewa / Museum of New Zealand
- National Library of New Zealand / Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa
- Hocken Collections / Te Uare Taoka o Hākena
- Trove Newspaper Archive / The National Library of Australia
- "Treasures of the Dunedin Public Art Gallery" by Peter Entwisle, 1990
- Lemuel Lyes Photograph Collection (used with kind permission)
- Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision Archives
- Images from my personal collection

Sunday, 27 October 2024

Larnach Castle - The Purdie Years (1927 to 1940) - Part Three


Larnach Castle at it appeared pre-1935. Part of Mrs Purdie's
Rock Garden appears in the foreground along with a small
"German Dwarf". Note also the carving on a plinth behind.
[Credit : Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive]

This Continues my eight part Blog Series on the Purdie family ownership of Larnach Castle. To Read the First Instalment in this series please click HERE


Mrs Purdie's Garden Installations

Today we shall explore how Mrs Purdie's vision, and that of her Head Gardener, Mr Ira Vincent Thornicroft (b. Dunedin 1903, d. Gwelup, Western Australia 1984, aged 81), created a beautifully laid out Victorian style garden to grace the Castle and which would be greatly admired and enjoyed by so many visitors during the 1930's. And also which elements of her beloved garden are still evident today. I would stress that this is not a definitive description (i'll leave that to Mrs Barker) but rather a general overview of some historical features including specific detail I have noted in photographs and which I believe are worth highlighting. 


Mrs Laura Purdie,
Taken 25 Dec 1927
[Credit : Mrs L. Hormann]

Mrs Purdie herself is also noted as having been “an avid gardener” and laid out the gardens “in the Victorian style”. Her legacy and vision, and that of her Head Gardener,  Mr Thornicroft, can still be viewed today in the rockery (only part of which appears in the top photo), now being known as the “lost rock garden”, and having been “the pride and joy of both it’s creator and owner”. After the Purdie’s departed it would became neglected, overgrown and quite literally 'lost', only being rediscovered after Mr Thornicroft paid a visit many years later and alerted the Barker’s to its existence, then being hidden by a 'jungle' of trees and undergrowth. The said rockery had also contained a “bridge, pond, grotto, and stream”, of which there was now no visible evidence. So, all in all, very hidden indeed.

Their niece, Mrs Lorna Hormann recalled that Mr Purdie employed men from his Castle Street wood and coal company to help move the rocks to form the rockery which would cover a third of a hectare. There was a union strike but since they needed money for their families, Mr Purdie discreetly trucked them up to the Castle where they agreed to work without being seen. I believe Mr Purdie, with his strong Christian values and hospitable nature would, like William Larnach, have been a fair and respected employer. 

Larnach himself is remembered as “an honourable man” and is in fact known to have been exceedingly kind and generous to his workmen. I even noted that he had acted as Witness for a Groomsman's marriage, signing his name in the Peninsula Presbyterian Parish Marriage Register. Hardly, at least in regards to his staff, the “arrogant and autocratic” man that Historian Hardwicke Knight sadly avers he would become later in life.


Mrs Purdie's Goldfish Pond & Italian Fountain,
Taken pre-April 1934
[Credit : Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive]
 

Another inspired garden installation created by the Purdie’s is a raised Italianate style circular front lawn with a central goldfish pond. Mrs Hormann recalled that her Aunt purchased the still extant single tier marble fountain for the pond while on a trip to Venice while Mrs Barker additionally states that it specifically came from Pisa. The fountain, which now creates an elegant water feature, actually went missing in transit to New Zealand and never turned up. Apparently “years later” it was spotted by a friend – all wrapped up, correctly labelled, and for whatever reason – sitting in a Sydney shipping warehouse. It had assumedly been off-loaded for trans-shipment but then simply overlooked and somehow forgotten. If you've read my Blog on the much travelled 'unkucky' Tokomairiro Presbyterian Church bell you will know that much stranger things have indeed occurred.


A close-up of the Italian Fountain.
The "Ibis" and "Frog" are highlighted.
Taken pre-April 1934
[Credit Miss MTL Watson / Genfram Image Archive]

The fountain was then, no doubt with some relief, sent on the final leg of its journey and installed where it remains to this day. I note that is has, however, since lost the small round circular carved acanthus finial above the upper fountain trough just under where the water was ejected. I personally think it maybe looks better without it but it does appear to be a traditional feature of such fountain design. Mrs Purdie also placed a carved ibis and frog in the goldfish pond beside the fountain, the Ibis noted as being repaired by the new owners in 1945, but sadly, neither feature are extant today. A 1937 visitor refers to the "fish pond" so it would definitely appear to have then contained goldfish.

A no longer extant feature on the raised front lawn were four defined pathways, roughly on a north, west, south and east axis which extended from still extant side steps and joined a central pathway around the fish pond. But far from being pebble pathways, they look decidedly stoney and were possibly stone chips from past building work, so perhaps not exactly comfortable to walk across in light footwear. These pathways, which you can just see a portion of in the upper pond photo above, unfortunately appear to have disappeared by the 1940's, possibly for ease of lawn maintenance. Together with the still extant pond and fountain, the pathways were a quite striking feature of the front lawn design. You will be able to see a good framed photo of the original front lawn design hanging in the corridor leading to the Castle ballroom café.  


One of Mr Purdie's "German Dwarfs"
[Credit : National Library of New Zealand]

Another no longer extant but rather intriguing feature of Mrs Purdie's garden were a number of "German Dwarfs", most, I gather decorating a "Little Rockery". And did you spot the one hiding in the "Lost" Rock Garden in the very top photo? This larger one with a peaked drooping hat is positioned beside the entrance to the entrance to the Ballroom corridor and basement level of the Castle. I note that this same dwarf also appears in the late 1920's photo of the Castle I featured in Part Two of this series so had been a long-term and intriguing guardian silently greeting guests entering the ballroom and café corridor, then being the only public access from the garden. 


A 1930's Photo of the Garden Pergola
[Credit : "The Ordeal of William Larnach, 1981]

The elegant etched glass cupola in the Castle gardens is of great historical interest. Mrs Purdie herself confirms that "the little round summer house in the grounds" was her inspiration and that the dome, being of "french glass", came from the "Paloona, one of the Union Steam Ship Company vessels". In her memoirs, her niece Mrs Hormann also speaks of it, stating that it had stood above the saloon in what she termed; “Mrs Purdie’s favourite ship”. 

This was in fact originally the former Huddart Parker Line 2771 ton triple expansion steam ship “Zealandia” (built 1899 in Dundee) which, in 1908, was purchased by the Union Steam Ship Company and then re-named “Paloona”. Described as a “stately” vessel, the "Paloona" then served the Company on the Trans-Tasman, Inter-Island and Pacific routes until laid up at Port Chalmers in 1922.  It would be during her service with the company that Mrs Purdie came to know the vessel. The 1899 "Zealandia" should however not be confused with earlier sailing vessels of the same name. While referred to as from a "sailing ship" in a Castle information handout I note that it has been correctly attributed to the "Paloona" on one of their information boards and additionally, is also correctly attributed to the "Zealandia" / "Paloona" in the Heritage New Zealand website entry. 



The restored Cupola as is appears today.
Note the gold painted finial.
[From my own collection]

In March 1928 the "Paloona" was stripped of her fittings before “her dilapidated shell” was towed out to the Otago Heads and sunk at The Mole to act as a breakwater. When the ship’s fitting were sold in 1928, Mrs Purdie was able to purchase the dome and with her usual vision and flair had it erected in her garden on six decorative cast iron supports which are also of historical interest. While these would appear to have been erroneously attributed to having come from a shop veranda, Mrs Purdie helpfully tells us that they were in fact the original "upright supports" that had supported the lamps on; "the old Leith Street Bridge". I note that the Leith Street Bridge over the Water of Leith had been washed out in a flood on the 19th to 20th March 1929 and fully replaced so the time period certainly fits but I can find no period photo of the said bridge to support this specific attribution. 

Atop the dome Mrs Purdie placed a round pointed finial that had originally graced one corner of the Castle roof. After vandalism and a fallen cedar tree branch had sadly taken its toll and smashed some of the curved and painted glass it was expertly replicated and replaced some years ago, no doubt at some considerable cost.



"Princess Charlotte" (and other objects) which
Mrs Purdie placed under the Cupola, c.1929-1930
Note also the croquet hoops at left rear.
[Credit : Te Papa Tongarewa]

Mrs Purdie would, after the installation of her "Summer House", add decorative items with a distinct nautical theme. Under the dome, Mrs Purdie placed, as confirmed by Mrs Hormann, a ship's figurehead of “Princess Charlotte” with a date of "1821" on a plaque. After the Purdie’s temporarily left the Castle in March 1937 this same figurehead would purportedly be found dumped in Otago Harbour before being duly returned but I have no further details of this incident. The bust is at least confirmed to have still been under the dome after the Purdie's departure, being noted by an Australian traveller who, with some difficulty, had arranged a visit to the Castle with a Larnach family member just the day after the property was temporarily leased. 

Princess Charlotte” would refer to Princess Charlotte of Wales (1796-1817) and daughter of George, Prince of Wales and Prince Regent (later King George IV). As to the provenance of the figurehead; "It was an effigy of Princess Charlotte and as far as [Mrs Purdie] could ascertain came from the Royal Navy frigate Princess Charlotte, built in 1821 and destroyed by fire in the Far East some years later". 

The vessel Mrs Purdie refers to was in fact launched in September 1825 and knowing that; "His Royal Highness the Prince of Cobourg [sic Coburg]" (Prince Leopold of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha, being the late Princess Charlotte's former husband) desired to perform the ship's christening ceremony in memory of his late wife at least confirms the correct attribution to the afore-mentioned "Charlotte". 

But I now seriously believe that the figurehead is not actually from the 1825 "HMS Princess Charlotte". Firstly, it does not match the detailed description of the figurehead given in the "Hampshire Chronicle" after her launching. And secondly, Maritime Historian Stephen Davies, writing in the 2022 journal of the Hong Kong Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society, not only tells us that the figurehead was removed from the ship in Hong Kong before being towed to Canton (now Guangzhou) for scrapping in 1875, but that it was still extant in Hong Kong in 1933. He even provides a grainy photograph of the said figurehead which is disimilar to Mrs Purdie's and more closely matches the description given in 1825. All Mrs Purdie could otherwise tell us about it was that, "the figurehead had been purchased by her about 1928".

Unfortunately I can find no other vessels (naval, merchant or passenger) by this name with a specific launch date of "1821" and we only have Mrs Purdies belief (no doubt having been told at purchase) that it was specifically a Royal Navy vessel which we can now, I believe, consider as totally erroneous. The figurehead's true provenance unfortunately appears to have truly been lost in the mists of time.

As to the fate of this object, in 1952 Mrs Purdie gifted it to the "Sea Scouts", having obviously kept it after the 1940 sale of the Castle and most of the contents. In 1965 the figurehead would again (assuming the first reference is correct) suffer another 'dunking' in Otago Harbour having; "been removed from a store at the rear of the cadet training ship, Waireka, and thrown into the water by intruders." It was found and safely returned. I am currently trying to ascertain if the Navy Cadet Unit still retain the said figurehead and will update this entry if further information comes to hand. But needless to say, the original origins of the figurehead now requires further detailed research which may still elicit something. 

As to the other two objects, one is an; "Old Cannon Ball Found on Otago Peninsula Date Unknown" for which I have no further information as to its current whereabouts, and the other object is a small cannon which has a most fascinating history. I will be featuring this historical artefact in Part Four. Note, however, the old decorative wooden lath pergola at the rear in its original position beside the glasshouse, having been erected here in Larnach's day.


"The Duchess" (highlighted), shown in a 
circa 1940's photo
[Credit : Used with the kind permission of Lemuel Lyes]


In the gardens today, there is still the small but well-known bust of “The Duchess” which sits on a plinth fronting the driveway, being a character drawn by artist John Tenniel in 1865 for Lewis Carroll’s novel “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland”. According to Mrs Barker, this garden feature, including one of the Knave of Hearts, were both installed during the ownership of the Purdie family in the 1930's and "The Duchess" can certainly clearly be seen in the above circa early 1940's photo.

Two yew trees on the lawn fronting the ballroom were also, according to Mrs Barker, planted by Mrs Purdie.


The old Lath Trellis Pergola
as viewed from the domed cupola.
Taken circa 1929-1930
[Credit : Te Papa Tongarewa]


The above decorative trellis pergola had been an original pre 1898 feature of the gardens and since Larnach’s day stood near the present day perennial flower border (known as The Serpentine Walk), primarily with a north south aspect and close to the glasshouse. A later circa early 1940's photo shows the above pergola had been moved over to and further back on the front lawn enabling, when standing within it, a beautifully framed vista of the Castle frontage together with the pond and fountain. I will feature this view in a later Blog. I am assuming that Mrs Purdie had the pergola moved to this new position after the completion of the Italianate raised front lawn and the installation of the central fish pond and fountain. The pergola is now a permanent (metal work) garden feature in the same position and known today as the “Labernum Pergola”.’

Larnach's Glasshouse with Decorative Gable Ends.
Only the central wall and bases survive today.
[Credit :  "The Ordeal of William Larnach, 1981]

Mrs Purdie and her Gardeners will also have made good use of Larnach’s large glasshouse located on the sunny northern side of the Castle. This was divided along the centre by a brick wall with one whole side being a vinery. After falling into disrepair, including a fire in the 1950's which destroyed much of the structure, only one part of the original roof glazing appears to survive today (or at least looks similar to the earlier version) although the two ends and doorways still appear fairly original. You can also see the glasshouse behind the lath pergola in the above photo from circa 1929-1930. 

So overall a number of features and improvements which formed both William Larnach's and Mrs Laura Purdie’s vision for the gardens are incorporated in and add historical layered elements to the very considerable work undertaken by Mrs Barker since 1967. The seven acres of maintained gardens are now rated by the New Zealand Gardens Trust as a Garden of International Significance. Mrs Purdie would surely have been delighted that her beloved garden continues to not just delight visitors but has continued to evolve and expand. I do recommend Mrs Barker's comprehensive publication; "The Garden at Larnach Castle" (clickable link) and which includes many snippets of history which I have only touched on here.


The "Monster Garden Party" held
at the Castle, Saturday 11 October1930

The 1930 "Monster Garden Party"

Notably, on Saturday the 11th October 1930, Mr and Mrs Purdie would generously host a “Monster Garden Party” under the auspices of the Baptist Church Union during their 48th annual conference in Dunedin, with delegates attending from all parts of New Zealand. With admission to the grounds by private car or taxi reduced to one shilling (or two shillings and sixpence by bus from Dunedin), the Anderson’s Bay Orchestra would play on the lawn, while delegates could join “specially conducted” tours of the Castle and up to the tower for an extra two shillings and sixpence with a visit to the Ballroom Antique Gallery reduced to just sixpence. Full catering was provided. Providing a wonderful venue, upwards of 700 to 800 guests were entertained with the whole of the proceeds, being £80.0.0 being donated towards Conference expenses. I gather, from the published recollections of Mrs Lorna Hormann, that local Baptist Church picnics in the grounds were also held quite regularly.

We shall now enter into some increasingly uncertain, and indeed turbulent, years in the Castle's many layered history. 


All Rights Reserved


This eight part Blog series featuring the Purdie family and their ownership of the Castle follows a more or less consecutive timeline through the highs and lows for this period. Please click HERE to read the next instalment.

Corrections : This history has been compiled from a comprehensive range of secondary sources. Correction of any unintended errors and any relevant additions in relation to the time period in question are always welcome. Please email me (quoting your source) using the "Email Me" button in the right-hand menu bar. Thank you.

Bibliography & Sources :

- “King of the Castle” by Fleur Snedden 1997 (from my own collection)
-“Larnach and His Castle” by Alfred H. Reed, 1950 (from my own collection)
-“The Ordeal of William Larnach” by Hardwicke Knight, 1981 (from my own collection)
-"R.A. Lawson Victorian Architect of Dunedin" by Norman Ledgerwood (from my own collection)
-“The Garden at Larnach Castle” by Margaret Barker, 2006
- Larnach Castle Staff & Website https://www.larnachcastle.co.nz/
- McNab Room Collection & Librarian, Dunedin Public Library
- "Papers Past" [National Library of New Zealand / Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa]
- (Published) Recollections of Mrs Lorna Mortimer Hormann (née Duncan), 2010
- “The Press” Newspaper, Christchurch
- "The Otago Daily Times" 
- American Express “Insight” Magazine
- Miss MTL Watson / GenFram Image Archive (held by the writer)
- Te Papa Tongarewa / Museum of New Zealand
- National Library of New Zealand / Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa
- Hocken Collections / Te Uare Taoka o Hākena
- Trove Newspaper Archive / The National Library of Australia
- "Treasures of the Dunedin Public Art Gallery" by Peter Entwisle, 1990
- Lemuel Lyes Photograph Collection (used with kind permission)
- Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision Archives
- Images from my personal collection